Another exciting week of college football on the way! This is when we start to really learn who's who. Most teams are done playing non conference teams and the games that matter are here. Clemson was able to outlast North Carolina in a 1 point victory on the road, while Ohio State, Alabama, and Oklahoma continue to destroy every team in sight. Is Clemson still an automatic final four team? I'll get into that but besides what's happening on the field, there's plenty to talk about off of it.
CALIFORNIA FAIR PAY BILL
It has long been a debate about where college athletes can/should be paid. For years people have debated the topic, some strongly for and some strongly against. Many schools have been heavily sanctioned, many coaches have been fired for providing what the NCAA sees as unfair benefits to the "student" athlete. From the days of Reggie Bush having his Heiman trophy taken away, to the case of Cam Newton and whether or not he and his family took money and of course Johnny Manziel who singlehandedly made Texas A&M one of the hottest schools in the country. This week the Governor of California officially signed a bill that would give college athletes the right to profit from their name, image, and likeness effective 2023. It's a long time coming in my opinion. I have never understood the concept of big time players bringing millions of dollars to a school and everyone profiting from it except for that player. The Terrell Pryor case comes to mind. He autographed a couple items of apparel from Ohio State that were his for a discount on a tattoo and the media world lost their mind. However, they didn't have an issue with the school clothing stores, online sites, and more selling plenty of Terrell Pryor jerseys and other items. Same for Johnny Manziel and many others. The system has never been fair but hopefully this is a step in the right direction. A state like California can set a tone for this and once other major states such as Texas, Florida, etc come on board it will be almost unstoppable for the NCAA. But why would they want too? You listen to Tim Tebow come on First Take and give an asinine take on players getting paid. He literally spoke from a privileged spot that 80% of college athletes can't relate too. He dove deep about how he wanted to play for the passion of the school his grandfather attended and that's why he didn't care to get paid. Tim wants to play for free due to passion for his family and he never thought about the MANY players who are playing for free and their parent(s) are back home struggling to keep the lights on. This rule will help so many student athletes and force the millionaire athletic director and coaches to share some of those profits that the player brings in. I mean we live in a world where a player can't even have his own YouTube channel without being threatened that his scholarship would be revoked and his eligibility would be over. Former Virginia star Kyle Guy recently was getting married, and his fiancé put their registry on her Facebook for their friends and family. Fans of Guy began purchasing gifts for the couple and the NCAA stepped in immediately to have them shut it down. Where's the fairness in that? Hopefully this sparks a major change on the college sports landscape. And hopefully they bring back the NCAA video game!
REVISITING THE NCAA REDSHIRT RULE
So it's been a year since the new NCAA rule has been in affect allowing players who see game action in 4 games or less to redshirt and we've seen multiple players take advantage of it. The person thriving most now is former Georgia quarterback Justin Fields, now at Ohio State , as well as former Alabama quarterback Jalen Hurts who is now a starter at the University of Oklahoma. Also Kelly Bryant is starting at Missouri, while Jacob Eason is leading the Washington Huskies to what looks like will be a successful season. With the success we've seen, is the rule still a good and effective rule?
It recently came up again as Houston quarterback D'Erick King announced he would redshirt the rest of the season. He did mention that he would likely stay with Houston but not many people are buying that including myself. He says this 2 weeks after a matchup where Houston played well against Oklahoma and after the game Sooners head coach Lincoln Riley stated he didn't know if there were 5 better quarterbacks in the country than King. Now, I feel that there are at least 10 better but that's beside the point. King will now likely transfer to a new school after starting at Houston for the beginning of the year.
Also , Caylin Newton, younger brother of Cam will be entering the transfer portal as well after starting his team's first 4 games at Howard. So the subject has recently been a topic of various college football shows, even prompting college football analyst Joey Galloway to state the redshirt rule is "terrible for college football".
I completely disagree. While I understand the negatives, such as playing 4 games and then leaving the program putting both your team and coach in jeopardy, I also think the positives far outweigh them. The coach can leave a program literally whenever he wants and it happens all the time. Coaches will come to a recruit's home, sell them on being there 3-4 years and then leave the following offseason i.e. Willie Taggart. Players should have the right to do what's best for them, just like coaches, and AD's. You only get one life, one time to experience college athletics to the fullest. If you feel another situation will contribute to a better you, a better chance of accomplishing your dreams, it's your right to take that chance. Let people call it selfish, but I guarantee if those people had a chance to chase their dreams they wouldn't let anyone stop them either. And while I don't want to see college athletics turn into full time free agency every year, I am more than fine with guys following their dreams and the chance to make it to the next level.
EARLY TOP 4
Now finally I can talk some on field stuff and it's still early in the year and this list may change between now and Selection Sunday but I feel I can definitely say who the top 4 teams in the country are as of now. The order may surprise you.
1) Ohio State They have been unreal this year. Dominating every opponent they line up with. Justin Fields has transitioned extremely smooth to this team and can literally put them on their back. He doesn't have many weaknesses offensively and can throw and run the ball equally well. The defense is dominant as well. I haven't believed in a Ohio State team this much in awhile.
2) Alabama - Slightly less dominant but as the saying goes every year, Alabama is Alabama. Tua has been amazing this year and is likely set for another visit to New York when the season ends, and his receivers may be the best in the nation. The defense is great, not as good as some other ones but still elite enough to continue their annual run to the playoff.
3) Clemson - Having the nation's longest winning streak Clemson can't go any less than 3. People try and make a big deal about them not blowing out teams the way they did last year but to win 20 gams in a row is tough,. You get everyone's best shot, hence North Carolina going for the 2 point conversion instead of the tie last week. Clemson's defense is still ELITE. Trevor Lawrence is still a top draft pick, and they have several offensive players that will definitely play on Sundays. Clemson is just bored. They'll still be undefeated and heading to another playoff.
4) Georgia - Georgia may be flying under the radar for most but they are still a great team. Jake Fromm who I didn't think was an NFL quarterback a year ago continues to make strides, and the running game and defense is as good as ever.
Other quality teams that I considered:
LSU- Great defense and an offense that can pass better than they can run
Oklahoma- Hurts and the offense are amazing, but what happens when they line up with a quality opponent
Wisconsin - Elite running game and defense
Auburn - Dominant running game, and a great defense. We'll learn more as their freshman quarterback starts to play some bigger games
WEEK 6 PICKS
Oklahoma State (21) VS Texas Tech
This should be a high scoring matchup with plenty of offense on both sides of the ball. Chuba Hubbard is one of the best players in the country and can be a one man show at times, while Texas Tech is relying on a junior quarterback who looks to be ready for the spotlight. I don't expect a lot of defense in this game but I'm excited for a shootout.
Oklahoma State 41 Texas Tech 30
Iowa (14) VS Michigan (19)
I don't have a clue why Michigan is still ranked in the top 20. If there's a team who hasn't impressed me this year, its them. Iowa is a better team on both sides of the ball and I expect them to show it despite being the road team. This will likely continue Michigan's slide as Harbaugh is probably gone at year's end.
Iowa 24 Michigan 14
Auburn (7) VS Florida (10)
Auburn impressed the hell out of me last week in completely dismantling Mississippi State. A balanced rushing attack and an efficient passing game is exactly what you need in the SEC. Florida has looked a lot better to me since quarterback Kyle Trask took over for the injured Felipe Franks. The offense seems to move better and more efficiently as well. The defense is still really good which makes them a true contender in the East this year. Can Box Nix go win in the Swamp? It'll come down to the playcalling from Gus Malzahn to put them in positions to succeed.
Auburn 27 Florida 17
Michigan State (25) VS Ohio State (4)
Michigan State has a really good defense, a solid running game, and good coaching. I just don't think it matters much. Ohio State is well oiled machine and while they may be able to somewhat slowdown Justin Fields and that offense, that likely means holding them to 40 instead of their normal 50 plus. The Spartans will compete for about a half, and then you'll look up and they're down 30.
Ohio State 41 Michigan State 17
California VS Oregon (13)
With a big road game looming, losing your starting quarterback is probably the worst thing that can happen to a team. Unfortunately for the Golden Bears, that's exactly what happened as quarterback Chase Garbers will be out for an extended period of time. The coach is preparing to play both backups this week which may keep the Oregon defense guessing. Oregon has rebounded nicely from the early loss to Auburn and seem to be back on track. Quarterback Justin Herbert continues to be great as he still has yet to throw a pick this year. Cal's defense is really good, but probably not good enough to stop Oregon from moving the ball.
Oregon 34 California 17